Why Police Recruiting Feels Harder Than It Should!

Thanks for reading the Marketing 'For Cops' Newsletter. Want this newsletter delivered straight to your email every week so you don't have to remember to check LinkedIn? Join my Police Marketing Squad and I'll send it to you every Thursday morning! Forever free, always delivering knowledge, and never spam!

If police recruiting feels harder right now than it ever used to, let me start by telling you something very important. You’re not crazy. In many ways it is.  But, before you go jumping onto the “see, nobody wants to do this job anymore” bandwagon, I need to clear something else up…that’s not the reason why. 🤯

You see, what’s actually happening is that police recruiting hasn’t gotten harder. It’s gotten noisier.  And that noise has left you confused, frustrated and not knowing what to do next. 🫤

Want me to show you how to cut through that noise so you can take back control of your police recruiting? Keep reading! 👀

Hey everyone, it’s Tom Sye your Police Marketing FTO, and this week, we’re talking about something that lies underneath almost every recruiting problem I see agencies struggling with right now and it’s not pay, it’s not benefits, and it certainly isn’t from a lack of trying on your part. 💪

The problem with police recruiting right now is…there are more voices, more opinions, more tools, more platforms, and more ways of doing things than ever before.  When you couple that with very persuasive salespeople coming out of the woodwork telling you that if you just implemented their one solution, everything would magically fix itself, it’s easy to see why you just want to rip the volume knob off your recruitment stereo and forget about the whole thing. 😵

Listen…you don’t have to feel overwhelmed anymore.  You don’t need to be confused. And you don’t need to be frustrated to the point you’re looking for a new assignment.  What you need is some good old-fashioned knowledge.  🧠

So, let me give you just that. Here are the three main reasons why police recruiting feels way harder than it should right now, and what you can start doing differently to take control of your police recruiting...

1. You’re reacting instead of recruiting

For the most part, agencies aren’t actually recruiting anymore…they’re reacting. 😺🐭

Low applicant numbers?  We gotta do something.  Another agency posted something on social media?  We gotta post that too.   Read a headline, notice the latest social media trend, or take a sales call about a new proprietary marketing product?  Let’s jump on that too before we have command staff asking why numbers are down again. 😰

Look, when recruiting becomes reactive, everything turns into a scramble. Random posts. Random ideas. Random efforts with no real direction. And when you have no direction, that’s when you get exhausted, start feeling uncomfortable and frustrated by the whole thing.  😑

Here’s the shift…

Police recruiting, just as it has always been, works best when it’s an intentional act, not an emotional reaction. You need a plan. 💯 

Take the time to figure out what message it is you want to deliver, who exactly that message is for, and most importantly, what you want that person to do next after hearing it.  When you do that, everything gets simpler because you’re no longer chasing fixes, you’re directing people and building momentum. 🧭

2. You’re trying to impress candidates instead of relating to them

This is a sneaky bad one for a lot of agencies because you got all these outside companies telling you over and over again this is the way you should be doing things. 👎️  

So, in an effort to look professional, more impressive, or even elite, your recruiting content often becomes stiff, way overproduced, and completely disconnected from the very people you’re trying to reach. 🔌

Here’s the reality of it and I really hope this sinks in…applicants are not looking for perfection.  They’re not looking for elitism.  They don’t want to see if they have what it takes or to be the best of the best. This isn’t Top Gun school, and their names aren’t Goose, Maverick or even Iceman or Slider for that matter. ✈️

Applicants are looking for familiarity. They want to see normal people just like themselves, making it through your process and doing the job well.  When everything you post feels corporate, scripted, or over-the-top tactical, you unintentionally tell a huge portion of your audience, “this place isn’t for you.” 🤷

The fix is super simple but incredibly powerful and I just alluded to it...

Show normal people doing normal police work. Real conversations, real moments, and a real look at what it’s like to work for your agency. That relatability builds trust faster than any fancy thing you could possibly post and is what keeps people leaning in instead of backing away. 🐈️

3. You’re measuring police recruiting effort instead of experience

This is the one no outside company will ever tell you about because they know, once you know it, their money train comes to a halt.   💥🚂 

It’s no secret most agencies measure recruiting success by using metrics and how much they’re doing. How many social media posts went out and how many likes did it get? How many recruiting events did we attend and how many people did we talk to?  What’s the reach on that billboard ad? What’s the average on website visits and how do we get them to stay longer? There certainly is no shortage of data and things for you to look at. 📊

But here’s the secret no one wants you to know…applicants are measuring something very different. They’re measuring how your process feels. How quickly they were acknowledged after reaching out to you. How clearly things were explained to them. How easy it was to get answers. How they were treated when they came forward and said “yeah, I’m interested”. 🙋‍♀️🙋‍♂️

You see, there’s no data for that…and you can’t find it on a spreadsheet. 🔭

Agencies winning right now are the ones who realize it’s not about analytics…it’s about having a feel for what’s going on with your people…and they’re paying heavy attention to their applicant’s experience throughout their process. They’re the ones that are making people feel seen, informed, and welcome early on…and then, work super hard to ensure that feeling remains right up through their date of hire and well beyond.  Doing this, and this alone, will separate your agency from most of your competition. 🏆️

Look, I know it’s a lot, but here’s what I want you to take away from this whole thing…

Police recruiting in 2026 isn’t broken. It’s just misunderstood. 🤔

You don’t need more noise. You don’t need more tools. And you definitely don’t need to hand your recruiting over to some outside company who doesn’t know your agency and is going to employ the same tactics they simply use for everyone else. 🙄

What you need is clarity. You need intention. And you need a recruiting approach that actually makes sense for today’s recruitment landscape. 🙌

That approach is exactly what I’m teaching you inside my Road to Better Recruiting online recruitment training course. It’s designed to get you up to speed quickly so you can stop guessing, stop reacting, and start recruiting with confidence and purpose. 😎

You can check it out right now on my website by visiting forcopstraining.com/rtbr and start recruiting like it’s 2026. 🚀

Know someone in recruiting who constantly feels overwhelmed, frustrated, or stuck with what they’re doing? Share this newsletter with them so they can learn too. They’ll be pumped that you did and I’d appreciate it too. 🤝

Have more questions about police recruiting, marketing, or anything else you're struggling with? Don't hesitate to reach out...I’m always here to help. 🙏

Until next week my Police Marketing Squad, happy recruiting! 😃

Tom

---

Did you find this newsletter valuable? Make sure to like & comment below. 👇

I'd love to hear from you! 🤩

Also, if you know someone who needs to see this content, please share my newsletter with them! I would appreciate the help in spreading the knowledge that will benefit us all and make our profession stronger! 💪

Have a marketing or recruiting topic you would like more info on? Drop me a message 📩 and let me know what you would like to learn! It might just make its way into next week's newsletter! 🤞

---

👋 I’m Tom Sye, your Police Marketing FTO. I founded ‘For Cops’ Training to teach Police Departments how to attract more qualified candidates through the same tried and tested methods I’ve used for the past ten years at my own department to keep up with turnover and stay ahead of vacancies.

Want to learn more about police marketing and recruiting? 👇

🔔 Follow my profile

✅ Connect with me

🗞️ Subscribe to the Marketing ‘For Cops’ Newsletter

You can also connect with me on Instagram, Facebook, X, or visit my website at www.forcopstraining.com to learn more about my Police Marketing courses which are enrolling right now!