Police Marketing 101: Likes Don't Equal Applications!

Thanks for reading the Marketing 'For Cops' Newsletter. Want this newsletter delivered straight to your email every week so you don't have to remember to check LinkedIn? Join my Police Marketing Squad and I'll send it to you every Thursday morning! Forever free, always delivering knowledge, and never spam!

If your police recruiting social media posts are getting likes, but your applicant numbers are not moving at all, I have a really simple explanation for this... 👇

Likes don’t equal applications. 🤯

And if you don’t understand why that is, social media will continue to frustrate you no matter how many likes you get. Let me clear the whole thing up for you and let you know what you should be looking for instead...keep reading! 👀

Hey everyone, it’s Tom Sye your Police Marketing FTO, and this week we’re talking about one of the biggest mindset traps agencies fall into when recruiting on social media and that is using likes to judge interest in your job openings.  ⚖️ 

Agencies all over the country are making posts, getting likes, and feeling pretty good about themselves, only to turn right around asking the same question they’ve been asking for months…‘why aren’t we getting any applicants?’.  🤔

Let me clear this whole thing up for you, because once you understand this shift, social media will become a whole lot less frustrating and a much more effective tool for your police recruiting. 🙌

Here are three reasons why likes don’t equal applications, and what you should be paying attention to instead...

1. Likes are passive, police marketing is not

Let me break this down for you…a like is the lowest-effort action someone can take on social media. I mean literally it takes a fraction of a second to do it, it requires no commitment, and most importantly, it doesn’t indicate that a person is ready to make a life-changing decision like becoming a police officer when doing it. 🤷‍♂️

Most people like posts the same way they nod their head when something makes sense. They agree. They relate. They keep scrolling. 👋

And that’s where agencies get tripped up. They see likes as progress, when in reality, a like just means your content was easy to consume. It doesn’t mean someone is ready to apply, looking reach out, or even seriously considering you yet. 🙅‍♂️🙅‍♀️

Recruiting, on the other hand, requires movement. It requires trust. It requires clarity. And it requires someone to feel confident enough to take that next step. 💪

So, when you judge your police recruiting success on social media by likes alone, you’re measuring comfort, not conversion. 🫤

The fix here is a simple but very powerful one. Stop asking, “Did people like this?” and start asking, “Did this move someone closer to understanding who we are and what it’s like to work here?” 💡

When your content is built around helping, explaining, and guiding instead of just being likable, applications will follow. 📈

2. Likes often come from the wrong people

This one is gonna sting a little bit, and it’s not meant to offend all of the co-workers, friends, and family in your audience, but it’s an important fact for you to realize...

A large percentage of the likes you’re getting are not coming from applicants. They’re coming from your own people, other cops, family members, community supporters, and people who will never in a million years apply for your agency. And there’s nothing wrong with that. 😎

Support is great, in fact I encourage agencies to actively seek those people for their audience…they’ll be your backbone. But if you confuse internal applause with recruiting impact, you’re going to keep wondering why nothing is changing. 💯

Here’s the reality. Most applicants, especially laterals, don’t hit the like button on recruiting posts. They’re classic lurkers meaning they watch, they observe, and they internally save. They think and think about if you’re right for them and talk things over with people they trust without you ever knowing any of it. 🥷

So, when agencies chase likes, they often start creating content that appeals to people who already like your police agency instead of people who are quietly deciding whether this job could be for them. 👎️

The fix here is to stop creating content for approval and start creating it for clarity. 🚀

Explain your process. Show normal people doing normal police work. Talk about what working for your agency actually feels like. Remove the fear, confusion, and mystery from your applicant’s decision-making process. 🔮

When you do that, the right people will take notice, even if they never hit the like button. 🧲

3. Likes don’t create momentum, direction does

Out of the three suggestions in this newsletter, this might be the biggest one, because it’s where most agencies lose the plot entirely. 😔

Listen, you can get a thousand likes on a post but if you don’t tell people what to do next, guess what, they’re not going to do it. 😳

Every social media post is a dead end unless you give a clear path forward. 🗺️

Applicants don’t magically start looking for things on their own. They need guidance. They need reassurance. And they need to know what step comes next if and when they’re ready. 🤗

When posts end abruptly without direction people stall. And stalled applicants go bye-bye. 👋

The fix here is to build intention into your content. 🫡

Every post should answer one of these two questions for every applicant. How do I learn more?  Or what should I do when I’m ready? 🎯

When your content starts answering those questions consistently, likes become even more irrelevant because movement starts happening behind the scenes. 🪄

People stop guessing...they stop hesitating...and they start reaching out to you because you encouraged them to do so. 🫶

Now...so there’s no confusion, here’s the big take away from this lesson...

Likes are not bad. They’re just not the goal. 😉

If you treat likes as validation, social media will always feel like a waste of time. But if you treat social media like the recruiting table it is, it becomes one of the most powerful assets you have in your arsenal. 💥

Remember...recruiting in 2026 isn’t about being popular. It’s about being understood. 😊

When you understand that, you’ll be the one filling vacancies while everyone else keeps staring at engagement numbers wondering where things went wrong. 🤩

Need some help building content that actually moves people from scrolling to seriously considering your agency?  My Road to Better Recruiting online training course has got you covered. 🤠

It’s designed to help you stop guessing, stop chasing vanity metrics like likes, and start recruiting on purpose! 😗

Check it out on my website by visiting forcopstraining.com/rtbr and start recruiting like it’s 2026. 🏆️

Know someone in police recruiting who is consumed by likes?  Share this newsletter with them so they can learn too. 🤝

Have more questions about police recruiting, marketing, or anything else you're struggling with? Don't hesitate to reach out...I’m always here to help. 🙏

Until next week my Police Marketing Squad, happy recruiting! 😃

Tom

---

Did you find this newsletter valuable? Make sure to like & comment below. 👇

I'd love to hear from you! 🤩

Also, if you know someone who needs to see this content, please share my newsletter with them! I would appreciate the help in spreading the knowledge that will benefit us all and make our profession stronger! 💪

Have a marketing or recruiting topic you would like more info on? Drop me a message 📩 and let me know what you would like to learn! It might just make its way into next week's newsletter! 🤞

---

👋 I’m Tom Sye, your Police Marketing FTO. I founded ‘For Cops’ Training to teach Police Departments how to attract more qualified candidates through the same tried and tested methods I’ve used for the past ten years at my own department to keep up with turnover and stay ahead of vacancies.

Want to learn more about police marketing and recruiting? 👇

🔔 Follow my profile

✅ Connect with me

🗞️ Subscribe to the Marketing ‘For Cops’ Newsletter

You can also connect with me on Instagram, Facebook, X, or visit my website to learn more about my Police Marketing courses which are enrolling right now!